|
Detroit News -
October 27, 2011
Millennials will save
Detroit
New ideas, fresh
faces needed to quash
recalcitrant politics
and policies of the past
By Morley Winograd and
Michael D. Hais
The Millennial
Generation is coming into adulthood and
asserting its leadership just in time to
engineer the rebirth of the city of Detroit.
These Millennials, born between 1982 and
2003, are people who believe in the rebirth
of urban America. Many grew up in the
suburbs but have found their way to the city
and now are working to foster fundamental
change through action and advocacy.
As John
Gerzema and Michael D'Antonio wrote in their
book, Spend Shift, they are people
like Rachel Harkai, who a few years ago was
a University of Michigan honors graduate who
waited on tables at the determinedly
optimistic Le Petit Zinc on Trumbull and
Howard to help make ends meet while she
pursued her writing career. Or Andrew Linn
and his older sister Emily, whose City Bird
shop on Canfield prospers by selling arts
and crafts created by artisans from Detroit.
They and many more like them are bringing a
bottom-up,
let's-take-action-at-the-local-level energy
that eventually will create a different, and
once again prosperous, Detroit.
And they're doing it because they love the
city.
"We're trying to dispel the notion that
there's nothing going on in Detroit," says
Kerry Doman, who grew up in Bloomfield Hills
and moved to Detroit in 2005 because, like
many postgraduates, she was "attracted to
the urban lifestyle."
Once she got to Detroit, however, she
realized that getting acclimated was more
difficult than it should be, so she started
After 5 Detroit, which connects young people
with things to do after office hours as well
as helps new residents.
Before a wholesale reincarnation will come
about, however, city leadership needs to
abandon beliefs and behaviors more suited to
the 20th century and embrace the ideas and
beliefs of a generation that will dominate
Detroit and the rest of America in the first
half of the 21st.
Doman agrees and says Mayor Dave Bing is
onboard with that as well. She's a part of a
group that meets quarterly with the mayor
and monthly with people from his office to
hear their concerns and take suggestions as
to how to make Detroit better for young
people.
Perhaps because the trajectory of Detroit's
rise during the industrial revolution took
the city higher faster than almost any other
place in America, it might have been
inevitable that Detroit would fall further
when the good times ended. In its heyday,
Detroit was the epitome of style and success
for industrial American cities.
Whether it was building an international
bridge and tunnel in record time (to
expedite the flow of illegal booze across
the border from Canada during Prohibition),
or funding the ambitious, soaring
architecture of Albert Kahn's skyscrapers to
house the ever-expanding corporate empires
of the auto industry, Detroit reveled in its
wealth.
Unfortunately, the city's leadership became
blinded by its success and could not see the
need to change before it was too late. As
Sue Mosey, the unofficial mayor of Midtown,
put it: "However great the culture was when
it grew … that culture stayed around way too
long."
Auto industry mistakes
It is the job of leaders to invent
alternative futures and enroll others in the
cause of making them come true. By that
standard, the leaders of Detroit's Big Three
automakers failed Detroit and its citizens
by failing to anticipate — let alone invent
or invest in — alternative futures as far
back as the 1970s.
Attempts to encourage the auto companies to
produce more fuel-efficient cars began
during the 1973-74 Arab Oil embargo, leading
Congress to establish corporate average fuel
economy standards that have recently been
raised to levels that will certainly test
the ingenuity of the industry's engineers.
In the 1990s, the Clinton administration
held out a helping hand in the form of the
Partnership for a New Generation of Vehicles
to provide more than $250 million for
research that would make such standards
easier to attain.
But when then-Vice President Al Gore met
with the CEOs of Detroit's automakers to
gain their support of the program, they paid
only lip service to the concept, lecturing
the government on the importance of profits
coming from SUVs and heavy-duty trucks. As a
result of this myopic approach, by 2009,
Ford, for example, found that only 7 percent
of Millennials considered its products when
shopping for a small car.
Brand loyalty matters
Brand image also has become paramount in an
age of rapid technological innovation, with
customers taking the role of discerning
designers. In this new marketplace, products
generate value based on the experience of
owning them, not their physical attributes.
Had the auto industry built a positive image
among environmentally conscious Millennials,
GM and its peers might have built sufficient
brand loyalty to help maintain their
financial footing.
Now, in an age of transparency and
peer-to-peer communications, the future
success of Detroit's Big Three rests on
their ability to win over the largest
generation in American history, whose
members are searching for companies that
convey a sense of purpose and meaning in
their products, not just in their public
pronouncements.
Unfortunately for Detroit, the organizations
that are attractive to Millennials today are
Google, Facebook, Apple, Disney and even
NASA and the CIA, not the automotive brands
car companies spend so much money
advertising.
Fortunately, however, there is a new
generation ready to restore Detroit's
greatness, building from the bottom up, not
from the top floors containing the C-level
executive suites at GM, Ford and Chrysler.
Reinventing Detroit
Millennials innately behave in concert with
the technology and beliefs of a new era.
Younger Millennials are being educated at
charter schools, such as University Prep, in
formerly abandoned buildings that have been
converted from their industrial-age uses.
They are attending college in record numbers
and just entering the age when they will
start families and settle down. This
generation wants to live in communities with
good schools in safe neighborhoods with jobs
and amenities they can get to easily. Most
of them grew up in suburbia and consider
such settings to be the ideal place to raise
a family.
Detroit has a unique opportunity, as
envisioned in a study done by the American
Institute of Architects, to create just such
environments in an interconnected group of
"urban villages," surrounding Detroit's
downtown core. These would be places where
people could walk to shops or restaurants
and, along the way, pass by parks and even
urban farms where acres of blight now darken
the landscape.
The founders of City Bird and 10 other young
Detroiters signed "The Detroit Declaration"
in 2010, demonstrating their readiness to
offer the city new leadership. They envision
a Detroit that "welcomes and embraces our
diversity, preserves our authenticity,
cultivates creativity, diversifies our
economy, promotes sustainability, and
enhances the value of city living."
The signers, and many other members of the
Millennial Generation, will use their values
to build this new Detroit because of their
commitment to civic life and the
institutions that enrich it.
This reinvigorated Detroit will come to pass
as soon as older leaders, still locked in
the paradigms of the past, get out of the
way and hand the reins of power to America's
next great generation: Millennials.
|